Revel in Creation Trigger: Insight

[Kharnage]

So the trigger reads "Shuffle any number of cards in your Discard Pile back into your Fate Deck."
there isn't any clarification on what cards go back into the deck. The implication, I believe, is that you pick which cards go, but someone in my meta is arguing it could be read as "from the top of the pile", which I feel doesn't have any basis here either. Any thoughts? 

[DumbLuck]

Which model is it on?

[Adran]

Pale rider. But the answer is probably going to come from the main rules. 

Edit

Or mechanical rider even. 

[Ogid]

1 hour ago, Kharnage said:

So the trigger reads "Shuffle any number of cards in your Discard Pile back into your Fate Deck."
there isn't any clarification on what cards go back into the deck. The implication, I believe, is that you pick which cards go, but someone in my meta is arguing it could be read as "from the top of the pile", which I feel doesn't have any basis here either. Any thoughts? 

It seems clear to me. You pick the cards you want and suffle them back, there is no instruction that force you to pick them from the top of the pile... Why does he think it's that way?

[CD1248]

I can't find anything that forces it to be from the top of the discard pile.

Plus, if it was off the top that trigger would go from "occassionally worth it" to only worth it in magical christmas land scenarios

[solkan]

Look at Big Brain Brin’s Calculate The Possibilities.

“Choose up to X cards from the discard pile” has to be from anywhere in the pile.  The Insight trigger has to be the same, at least because:

1.  You’re allowed to inspect your own discard pile, if you do it in a timely manner.

2.  Effects where you’re only allowed to take the top card of the discard pile say so.

 

[Mycellanious]

3 hours ago, Adran said:

Pale rider. But the answer is probably going to come from the main rules. 

Mech Rider XD