Mycellanious

*cries in Guild*

Out of curiosity, whats wrong with Mei Feng

Why?

You have to attack the feet first. Then, once you kill them that you take them off and the body slots into a 50mm base

It should be two 30mm bases, one for each foot

Idk this feels a lot like simply a clunkier version of what we already have, unless I supposed these new upgrade would be perfectly instituted and never need to be errated themselves. It would mean that keywords with one overperforming model would have all their models nerfed, or weak crews with one strong model would result in that model getting stronger. It feels inelegant, where the solution should simply be to buff one model, or nerf one, or take from one to give to another.

I've been playing a but of December on Vassal and I'll echo most of your points and add some more. 1. December's drains more of their own resources than their opponents. 2. They have a lot of 50mm models, and often mess up their own charge lanes. 3. In addition to 2, December oftens gives their opponents cover. In order to benefit from Harsh Winter or Sacrifice to December, the model needs to be near a Pillar, which often gives it cover since all your ranged attacks are projectiles. 4. They have almost 0 useful bonus actions. Most turns I dont use any bonus actions on any models, because they are all extrememly situational and only moderately useful. 5. Snow Storm sucks. He's very squishy and doesnt being much for 9 stones except anti-shooting. Mostly you hire him to shockwave your crew twice turn 1 and thats it. My potential solutions: 1. Allow Ice Mirror models to create a Pillar for free at the start of deployment 2. Allow the Ice Gamin and Golem to move through Ice Pillars. Alternatively, make it a leader ability for Raspy 3. Allow them to ignore Ice Pillars for determining cover 4. They need new bonus actions. Horcats should have Ambush definitely, and shouldnt need to discard a card for it when near an Ice Pillar. Tbh, what I would do is change Ice Pillars to a bonus action. This relieves some pressure and limits the number of Ice Pillars you can put out, so they can be better. 5. Snow Storm should get Hard to Wound if Wyrd wants him to be mele focused, or his bonus actiom should be able to target any minion or non-master December model (including himself) if they want him to fill a supportive role. Thoughts?

So the FAQ specifies that "Another" always means "Not the model taking the Action" excpet in cases where that doesnt make gramatical sense (ex. Another scrap marker) In the case of the Richochet trigger, that means RAW you can apply Richochet to the model you attacked (because it is not the model that took the Action and it is always within 3" of itself), so all models with Richochet have their damage tracks increased by 1/2/4. In addition, the FAQ clarifed that all triggers are subject to Focus and Accuracy Modifiers. So if you spend focus you get a positive to the attack and a positive to an additional 1/2/4 unavoidable damage on the same target.

I think you misunderstand, in the case of the Strategy friendly refers to friendly to the enemy. So, if Sparks puts his upgrade on a metal Gamin, that Gamin is attacked by Seamus, and the Blast from Seamus' attack, which was placed by Sparks because of the upgrade on the Gamin, kills a nearby Dead Doxy, who gets the kill credit? Is the Blast considered "generated by a friendly Seamus" or "generated by an enemy Sparks" or "generated by an enemy Metal Gamin" from the perspective of the Dead Doxy

If however, the action was a Replace, then it totally would count as the same model. Yan Lo can do this with his Reliquaries for instance

Sparks attaches Bombs In Yer Belly to a friendly model. Later, the Upgraded model is attacked by an Enemy, and the Blast resulting from that attack kills an Enemy. Who gets Bounty Tokens? A. Sparks, because he placed the Blast Market / Attached the Upgrade B. Any model friendly to Sparks in LoS, because the Blast was generated by an Enemy Attack Action C. No one because the damage came from the Upgrade\ Same question, but for the Explosive +3 Demise effect granted by the Upgrade. Same question again, but with regards to the Vent Steam Action.

2/3/4 irreducible, Onslaught, and stoning for Coordinated Strike from Kirai... its a blender

I was also refering to Vent Steam. Mei generates the Vent Steam action, but she doesnt generate the Walk action that killed Mad Dog

But was it an enemy controlled ability that killed it? The damage was taken because of the models own friendly walk action. Its there a difference between a model suiciding in Hazardous and being moved by and enemy effect inside hazardous with regards to kill credit?

I'm amazed how often people bring new crews to tournaments. Like, of course you arent going to make it to turn 5 if you've never played the crew. Of course you are going to run out of time if you own 7 crews and only played each twice. A big reason I can finish my games is because I own 2 crews, I've played them dozens of times, and even now 4 months into Rona I can tell you nearly everything about my Chimera models, and absolutely everything about my Foundry models, w/o looking