Sonnia's Flame wall and aSonnia Manifest Req

[Twisted Metal]

Sorry if this has been asked before but I did a search and couldn't find an answer. Anyway When Sonnia casts flame wall and an enemy walks though it does the damage sustained count towards Sonnia first avatar manifest Req? I can honestly see both sides of the argument. On one hand the flame wall could count as a separate source of damage just like all other severe terrain. On the other hand it has been rules in the past that the wall's damage is magical implying that it is still indeed a spell of Sonnia's after it has been cast. Thoughts?

[Lucidicide]

I think not, but cannot say conclusively.

[snord]

(removed to avoid confusion)

Edited March 23, 2012 by snord

[Hjelmen]

The first requirement is just doing 10 Wds with spells.

If the damage from the Flame Wall templates is magical, then it must come from the spell, but I can also see the other side of the point; that it is no longer a spell cast by Sonnia, but just a piece of hazardous terrain that causes magical damage.

[snord]

My bad... just looked over the cards and Hjelmen is right... any spells... not sure why I always assumed it was Flame Burst...

Anyway, in this case I would argue that yes, flame wall damage must count as it is a spell... and contrary to Rasputina's Ice Pillars, Flame Wall is hazardous, but does not say it is terrain.

[nix]

Flame Wall is generated from a spell, so any damage it does counts toward aSonnia's first manifest requirement.

@Snord has it.

[Requirement]

My bad... just looked over the cards and Hjelmen is right... any spells... not sure why I always assumed it was Flame Burst...

Because that's the way every Sonnia player accomplishes it? One big flame burst followed by manifestation?