Using the royal "We"?
I personally would put the picture of it from Wyrds' store as definitely in the horrible range. Right behind Avatar Marcus actually.
The reaction is, I believe, a bit worse than normal because:
a. People were really wanting this and wanting it to look good.
b. The preview pic left Candy out. That caused people to wonder why and I felt underwelmed when we saw the store pic.
That said, based on the word of the sculpter I am keeping my word and ordering Avatar Pandora here in just a minute.