Obey and Ashes and Dust

[ravenborne]

Can't find this anywhere. If Obey is used to make a model charge Ashes and Dust, and the charge then does no damage, is the model sacrificed at the end of its next activation?

Obey says "The Action selected may not cause the model to be

killed or sacrificed as part of the Action", but the action itself is not causing the model to be sacrificed...or is it?

[magicpockets]

Just to chip in on this -

1. RAW if you obey a model to charge an A&D from out of range it will do "no damage" and fills the criteria for the A&D to sacrifice it. All of the above is valid and I doubt RAI this was how it was meant to be played, but the points about "failed charges/strike actions" etc are superfluous as it stands, it is simply any charge which does no damage (which includes one from out of range). Also, I'm sure this has been ruled on previously...

2. Re obey and sacrificing, the thing to bear in mind is the model being obeyed isn't causing the sacrifice - the A&D is. (This hasn't been ruled afaik, but based on experience that's how these things tend to be explained/ruled)