Jump to content

Silas Cordell

Vote Enabled
  • Posts

    345
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Silas Cordell

  1. iWall sounds like a new Apple product...

    I've selected the strategies for the Saturday tournament.

    Round 1: Treasure Hunt

    Round 2: Beatdown

    Round 3: Line in the Sand

    I'd also like to add that while painting is not required, I do have a certificate for best painted, so it is worth something.

  2. That's covered by the "friendly crooligans ... affected by this spell" part in the second clause.

    How else can you read that part?

    Auras don't normally effect the model generating them, so even though it says "friendly crooligans," it would not normally effect the casting model. However, if the "including this model" clause is meant to mean the whole spell (rather than just the obscuring trait) it would.

    I don't think it's clear from the wording, might need a ruling.

  3. But you can't flip the BJ if it has already been flipped... Not that I actually believe that it should be taken into account, mind you.

    My point is that if you have to flip, the action will always be legal, as the number of wds is not fixed. Only actions that cause a fixed number of wounds become ineligible.

  4. You can't attempt an action that inflicts a flat (i.e. not variable) number of Wd on the caster if those Wds would reduce the model to 0 Wd remaining. In this case, you wouldn't be able to attempt the spell if the Lost Love only had 2 Wd left.

    But since you don't choose which effect you want (ie, which spirit you'll summon) until after the spell is successfully cast, shouldn't you be able to cast it as long as you have more than 1 wd (the minimum required)?

    ---------- Post added at 08:43 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:41 AM ----------

    I don't think this is correct. The rule forbids actions that, if succesful, are guaranteed to inflict enough WDs. The fact that the action may fail is not enough uncertainty to the killing, though if it can be resisted, then that is enough. Causing a variable number of wounds is also enough if the minimum amount is not enough to kill. Not quite sure if the chance of getting a Black Joker is enough. Especially if Black Joker has already ended up in the discard or if the player has it in his hand...

    Yeah, after checking the FAQ, I think you're right. I was thinking of the chance of resisting.

    The Black Joker shouldn't ever effect this, because anything that causes a variable number of wds (when you could flip the BJ) is always legal.

  5. I was under the impression that a model can not do any actions that kill it? Or is that just in regards to wd's?

    My understanding is that an action is only forbidden if it is guaranteed to inflict enough WDs to the model to kill it. Spells are always legal because you could fail the cast. Once the action has been declared, then the model may end up killing itself.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information