Can Izamu utilize Carve a Swathe off of a severe damage flip from hitting the Riposte trigger? I am looking solely for a Rules Marshal's word on this.
My argument is that it works, because, reading Lady Justice's v2 card, it says "as if she had made a Greatsword strike" at the end, where while Izamu does not, it is implied, in the same way Immune to Influence and Irresistible used to have wording. Furthermore, while Izamu did not use the (1) Strike action, Riposte when triggered creates retroactive action, in that the action is treated as if Izamu *did* make the strike.
the argument against mine ranges from the fact that Izamu did not make the strike action, to the fact that Riposte on Izamu says nothing about izamu making a strike.
I would very much like a Rules Marshal's word on this above anyone else's because I keep on getting mixed words from people ranging from experienced veterans of the game to people who also seem unsure but have some ideas of their own on the (slightly ambiguous) wording. This does need to be finalized in settlement.
Question
Kalkris
Can Izamu utilize Carve a Swathe off of a severe damage flip from hitting the Riposte trigger? I am looking solely for a Rules Marshal's word on this.
My argument is that it works, because, reading Lady Justice's v2 card, it says "as if she had made a Greatsword strike" at the end, where while Izamu does not, it is implied, in the same way Immune to Influence and Irresistible used to have wording. Furthermore, while Izamu did not use the (1) Strike action, Riposte when triggered creates retroactive action, in that the action is treated as if Izamu *did* make the strike.
the argument against mine ranges from the fact that Izamu did not make the strike action, to the fact that Riposte on Izamu says nothing about izamu making a strike.
I would very much like a Rules Marshal's word on this above anyone else's because I keep on getting mixed words from people ranging from experienced veterans of the game to people who also seem unsure but have some ideas of their own on the (slightly ambiguous) wording. This does need to be finalized in settlement.
Thank you.
~Lil Kalki
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Top Posters For This Question
13
11
7
6
Popular Days
Apr 16
20
Apr 14
16
Apr 19
10
Apr 13
7
Top Posters For This Question
Kalkris 13 posts
The Godlyness 11 posts
Omenbringer 7 posts
Paddywhack 6 posts
Popular Days
Apr 16 2013
20 posts
Apr 14 2013
16 posts
Apr 19 2013
10 posts
Apr 13 2013
7 posts
72 answers to this question
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.