Malfias Posted Tuesday at 06:52 PM Report Share Posted Tuesday at 06:52 PM Hello, I've read the Through The Breach core rulebook and I really like the setting and the rules. I like the moderate granularity of the rules and the atmosphere that emanates from them. I plan to introduce this system to my table of players. There is, however, one thing in the rules that gives me cause for concern. The range of most weapons. I find it incredibly low and therefore unrealistic. If I've understood the rules correctly, a weapon cannot fire beyond its range. And the basic range can only be increased by a Custom Action (modification) or Focused +1/+2/+3 for Rifles. I find the range of most weapons totally unrealistic. Rifles that shoot at 18 yards? Longbows that shoot at 12 yards? I mean... WHAT??? It's such a far cry from historical values. Gravity in Malifaux works differently and I'm not aware of it? :) Am I missing something obvious? Is it a balancing act? Is it because the game is derived from its miniature cousin? I know that the game isn't very simulationist, and that's why I like it, but I'm having a problem with this, because it's too far removed from reality. I hesitate to house rule this. Triple the value of all the ranges and make the first half shoot normally and the second half with a -1 card malus. This would make a longbow that shoots normally up to 24 yards and with a malus up to 48, and so on for all weapons with exceptions (lassos, cannons, etc.) that I wouldn't change. We'd still be a long way from reality, but we'd be getting a bit closer. I know that this would create a clear advantage for ranged weapons in terms of balancing, but I figure that in all indoor battles these ranges couldn't be used anyway, so melee characters would have plenty of room in the spotlight. What do you think? Thanks ;) 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Vorzakk 2.0 Posted Friday at 12:50 AM Report Share Posted Friday at 12:50 AM I concur, but I just took that as their way of keeping melee weapons relevant. What actually bothers me more is that a skilled knife-thrower can outrange a pistol. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.