Barbaros is being a jerk

[Four_N_Six]

So many moons ago, before I switched to gremlins for a while, Barbaros' sword arm broke off at the seam and now that I'm going back to NB for a while, I'm unsuccessfully trying to fix it. I've tried my modeling glue, tried gorilla glue, and it doesn't even get tacky to where it might stay after it dries. It's like in sticking then together with water.

I've  used my knife to shave it down a little so it's just plastic on plastic, figuring I'd green stuff the gap later, but it still won't hold. Any other ideas? I could probably get my friend to pin it if necessary, because I'm out of ideas. 

[Abbazabba1920]

Try zip kicker with gorilla glue. You just spritz the glued area and the glue dries in about 3 to 5 seconds.

[prof_bycid]

Pin it.  It will work and be a strong join.  I have had similar problems gluing old joins, and it can indeed be frustrating.