Okay a situation arose last night i'd welcome comment on.
Lynch attempted final debt last night which states that "target with the brilliance condition suffers damage equal to the hands in this models hand". He initially targeted Burt Jebson who, via slippery, wanted to pass the attack onto Gracie who didn't have the brilliance condition and therefore wouldn't suffer any damage.
Two views of ruling.
1. Gracie isn't a legal target because she doesn't have brilliance so can't have the attack passed on via slippery....or
2. The fact that Gracie doesn't have brilliance doesn't matter for the process of targeting in the first place so can in fact have the attack passed on which subsequently would cause no damage.
Thoughts and points of ruling would be useful....
I think it boils down to does a target need brilliance to be a valid target or not.
Question
SurreyLee
Okay a situation arose last night i'd welcome comment on.
Lynch attempted final debt last night which states that "target with the brilliance condition suffers damage equal to the hands in this models hand". He initially targeted Burt Jebson who, via slippery, wanted to pass the attack onto Gracie who didn't have the brilliance condition and therefore wouldn't suffer any damage.
Two views of ruling.
1. Gracie isn't a legal target because she doesn't have brilliance so can't have the attack passed on via slippery....or
2. The fact that Gracie doesn't have brilliance doesn't matter for the process of targeting in the first place so can in fact have the attack passed on which subsequently would cause no damage.
Thoughts and points of ruling would be useful....
I think it boils down to does a target need brilliance to be a valid target or not.
Thanks in advance.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Top Posters For This Question
14
11
11
9
Popular Days
May 18
38
May 21
27
May 20
15
May 23
13
Top Posters For This Question
Myyrä 14 posts
Dirial 11 posts
lusciousmccabe 11 posts
Kadeton 9 posts
Popular Days
May 18 2015
38 posts
May 21 2015
27 posts
May 20 2015
15 posts
May 23 2015
13 posts
Popular Posts
Kalkris
*sigh*... Grammar Pedant to the rescue, I suppose... If the characteristic in question was called "Brilliant", or if shorthand for "target model with the Brilliance characterstic" was "target Bril
lusciousmccabe
If the redirect doesn't care about legality then the new target should take the damage, Brilliance or no. The damage isn't contingent on the target having the characterisitic, so if you can legally pa
Myyrä
So you think they are humans? That's an interesting theory.
110 answers to this question
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.