I'm starting a TtB game with a group of new players, about half of whom are very new to RPGs (one has never played an RPG before). I've decided to run one of the Penny Dreadful one-shots for our first session, just to get them acquainted with the game mechanics. They'll have the option to use their own characters or start with a pre-gen if they want to see how the game plays first.
Right now I'm looking at Night of the Carver or Recruitment Drive, and they both seem like good starting adventures. NotC seems a bit more "think outside the combat"-heavy, since the Carver can't truly be killed, whereas RD is much more straightforward, and also gives the characters a reason to work together, rather than assuming they've already formed relationships. As you can see, I'm currently leaning more towards Recruitment Drive as a better starting point.
Can anyone who's already played through either of these give some feedback on their accessibility for new gamers? I'm also open to other suggestions for good starting one-shots.
Also, while I'm on the topic, would anyone be interested in play reports? There don't seem to be too many here (or maybe I'm just not finding them), but I've always enjoyed a good yarn and am considering writing up or recording our sessions. Thanks!