Howdy,
I'm new to Malifaux and am starting a Lucius crew and am looking to expand beyond the starter. So far I've grabbed a Guard blister and an Austringer. I'm pretty happy with my crew option for low SS games while I learn, but I want to get a totem to increase my Crew's effectiveness while not changing its playstyle.
Most places I've seen suggest a Drill Sergeant and I can definitely see the advantages there, but I do not want to rule out the Governor's Proxy right away.
The Drill Sergeant seems quite beneficial to boosting other Guardsman, and can also hang back with Lucius to act as Secret Service and be there to be sacrificed. But what worries me is his lesser casting ability whereas the Proxy is as effective as Lucius at casting and is also cheaper.
Has anyone compared these totems by battlefield testing before?
Also here are my potential 25 SS lists:
Guild Crew - 25 - Scrap
Lucius -- 2 Pool/3 Pool
Drill Sergeant [3ss] or Governor's Proxy [2ss]
Guild Austringer [5ss]
Guild Guard [4ss]
Guild Guard [4ss]
Guild Guard [4ss]
Guild Guard Captain [7ss]
(available models to add: Ryle or Lawyer)