As far as the effigies go, the Arcane one looks fantastic for him as it gets him more AP to cast stuff and more cards. He isn't a slouch and the ressers effigy ain't bad to take away those pesky immunity's. Other then that, the guild one seems lackluster unless you want a gun, the neverborn one masks fate flips which is cool, and outcasts like making jokers go back into your deck.
For collodi, this is how I would rank them.
1. Arcane
2. Res.
3. Neverborn
4. Guild
5. Outcast