for you bowen:
opponent sportsmanship: pleasure to play against(3pt), not the best but still fun (1pt), total jerk (w/ explanation 0pt)
opponent paint: Excellent Painting & Basing(5pt), Nicely painted and based (4pt), Painted but not based (3pt), Good Effort (2pt), Well there’s paint on them (1pt), Bare metal or primer (0pt)
I went back and reread the initial post. Sounds like 3 separate categories that have nothing to do with each other so sounds good. Read into Mavs too much thinking they all got combined together, my mistake.
Yes, awarding someone for their talent and time spent on miniatures is good. I'm fine losing that one