NIGHTS 5

Got the idea, but white on back is excess and too strong

It reminds me of a colorized black and white photo. Very creative.

Stepping out of the shadows...

The transitions are good and the light from the streetlamp works well, but maybe a bit too yellow. It would probably work better if the back of the model was a lot darker.

Good work. Maybe as they said before the back should be more darker.

nice warm OSL

Fun!

In contrast (no pun intended) to some of the other comments here I really like what you have done with the back of the model. It makes me think of some of the negative highlight schemes I've seen on Tara crews in the past and feels very fitting for Ivan's light/shadow magic theme.

Great colour transition from black and white scheme to colourfull part!

Wishing I had eyeballed this model closer sooner, the light from the lamp on the front mixed with the deep shadows really makes it pop, and gives him something to be shying away from, and I like the black and white contrast along the back, as if he's stepping out of a world without color and into what would inherently be far too bright light. 

Really nice use of multiple light sources. I think the highlights on the backside of the cape are too bright though.

Nice use of light sources and the monotone greys on the back are killer!

Very good glow from the lantern, the only thing is that it is very strong)

Like the color scheme. The author is well done, I advise you to add more shadows)

Magnificent!
The shading is perfect! The changing between of the yellow glow and the black and white shadows look awesome!