Jump to content

TheProfessor

Vote Enabled
  • Posts

    27
  • Joined

  • Last visited

About TheProfessor

  • Birthday 12/29/1960

TheProfessor's Achievements

Rookie

Rookie (2/14)

  • First Post
  • Collaborator
  • Conversation Starter
  • Week One Done
  • One Month Later

Recent Badges

3

Reputation

  1. This could be a a good opportunity to test out the beta rules for version 2! What do you think? I will be arriving on June 2.
  2. Good deal! I will likely be there June and July. When I know more i will post. Always intrigued by Infinty but have not played...
  3. Just revitalizing this post... I will be in Knoxville, TN this summer, and would love to find Malifaux players whilst there.
  4. I completely agree. And the "intent" of a spell called Expensive Gift would suggest that the target model is giving up one of their stones. So it seems reasonable that the target must have the Use Soulstone ability. But that makes me wonder if Magician's Duel is only allowed to be cast against another Magician (model with Use Soulstones)... And I think the official answer is going to be that they have different targeting rules, but I'm not sure why from the rules.
  5. Hmm. So with Expensive Gift, as the second part is an independent sentence ("Gain one Soulstone.") would that part go off, or is it something like "If you did make a target with Use Soulstone lose a Soulstone, then you can gain one Soulstone"? And related, with Magician's Duel, if the target did not Use Soulstone would you still be able to do the "If the target is killed by this spell gain one Soulstone"? I guess it is the same question posed twice - does the second part rely on the first part?
  6. I copied the entire text (except the damage and CC, etc.) in my first post. Both spells have the target "<model/targets> with use soulstone..." in the first sentence of the spell.
  7. Thanks folks. That was our instictual response, but the language is so similar between the two that we couldn't justify a different interpretation on the two: "Target model with Use Soulstone discards 1 soulstone" "Targets with Use Soulstone receive -2 Ca..." Both say something like "Target with Use Soulstone do this..." Really the only difference is "Target Model" vs. "Targets". So I'm trying to figure out how if there is some keyword or something here to make it clear?
  8. We had some minor confusion yesterday regarding targeting restriction, if any. Expensive Gift reads: Target model with Use Soulstone discards one Soulstone. Gain one Soulstone Magician's Duel reads: Targets with Use Soulstone receive -2 Ca resisting this spell. If the target is killed by Spell, gain one Soulstone. The question is: Can these spells target any model, regardless of whether that target has the Use Soulstone ability? If they can, does Expensive Gift generate a Soulstone regardless of whether the target had the Use Soulstone ability? It is a different sentence with no "if" or "then" attached to it... ?? Thanks in advance.
  9. Ambler, Pennsylvania, USA (near Philadelphia)
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information